6. Conclusions
We have examined whether corporate diversification is associated with accrual and real earnings management. While prior research focuses on the difference between diversified and nondiversified firms, our paper is the first to examine the non-linear relationship between corporate diversification and real and accrual earnings management.
We contribute to the literature by the following findings. First, we provide evidence on the relationship between corporate diversification and real and accrual earnings management. Recent research provides mixed evidence and, therefore, our findings contribute to this line of research by providing new evidence based on a large dataset. We show that diversified firms engage in real and accrual earnings management to manage their reported earnings upwards. Thus, our results are consistent with recent research (e.g., Farooqi et al. 2014; Jirapon et al., 2008) that finds that diversified firms engage in earnings manipulation. Second, and most importantly, we contribute to the literature by providing the first evidence on the non-linear relationship between corporate diversification and earnings management. Specifically, we provide the first evidence to the literature that diversified firms engage in accrual (real) earnings management, but this engagement is associated with level of diversification in a non-linear U-shaped (inverted Ushaped) relationship.
The findings of this paper therefore provide a new avenue for future research to consider the non-linear relationship when addressing earnings management in diversified contexts. Future research, for example, can examine how earnings management affects diversified firms’ value, but taking into account the U-shaped and inverted U shaped relationships.