Conclusions
We investigate the relationship between voluntary sustainability disclosure and earnings quality by examining whether sustainability disclosure quantity/quality is a substitute or a complement to earnings quality. Following Moon Jr. (2014), we classify earnings quality into innate earnings quality and discretionary earnings quality and, respectively, investigate their relationships to sustainability disclosure. We construct two measures of sustainability disclosures in our main tests, sustainability disclosure quantity as a proxy for whether the firm issues sustainability reports and sustainability disclosure quality of whether and how the firm using the GRI guidelines in the preparation and assurance of sustainability reports. Specifically, we constructed sustainability disclosure quality as the application level of the GRI guideline in preparing sustainability disclosure, an advanced version of the GRI guideline (such as G4) and level and type of assurance on sustainability reports.
We perform both DID tests and OLS regression and find that sustainability disclosure quantity is positively correlated with innate earnings quality and negatively correlated with discretionary earnings quality. Moreover, DID tests suggest that sustainability disclosure quality can significantly influence the relation between earnings quality and sustainability disclosure quantity. We find that the positive correlation between sustainability disclosure quantity and innate earnings quality is more pronounced when sustainability disclosure quality is high, and the negative correlation between sustainability disclosure quantity and discretionary earnings quality is less pronounced when sustainability disclosure quality is high. Finally, further tests suggest that the relation between earnings quality and sustainability disclosure is moderated by certain factors. Specifically, the positive relation between innate earnings quality and sustainability disclosure quantity tends to mitigate if firms did well in prior-year sustainability performance. Results suggest that the negative relation between discretionary earnings quality and sustainability disclosure quantity tends to mitigate if the institutional ownership is high.