DISCUSSION
Neuroanatomical diversity appears to account for a substantial proportion of the risk for ASD (29). However, and even though several candidate neuroanatomical biomarkers have been proposed, it is not yet clear exactly which neuroanatomical traits more strongly influence diagnosis. In this report, we looked at one specific structure, the cerebellum, that has been widely discussed in the literature. We performed a metaanalysis of the literature and an analysis of data from the ABIDE project.
The meta-analysis of the literature did not show conclusive evidence for a difference between patients with ASD and control subjects either for the total cerebellar volume or for its subregions. Total cerebellar volume and cerebellar white matter volume appeared slightly larger in ASD, whereas the area of vermal lobules VI–VII was found to be slightly smaller in ASD, but the significance of these results did not survive correction for multiple comparisons. Compared with a previous meta-analysis on total cerebellar volume and vermal areas (25), the effect sizes we computed were all smaller in absolute value. Specifically, Stanfield et al. (25) reported a significant difference in the volume of vermal lobules VIII–X. In our analysis, despite the fact that a larger number of studies was taken into account, we did not replicate their finding