4. Discussion and conclusions
According to the new UNECE Reg. no. 107 requirement smoke or heat detectors shall be installed in toilet compartments and driver sleeping compartments of buses. The performed tests have resulted in valuable information of what to consider when installing these detectors. Smoke detectors are generally much faster than heat detectors, which is also confirmed in all tests performed in this study. In the tests the fires have developed quite rapidly, but for slow growing fires the benefit of smoke detectors compared to heat detectors will be even greater. There are locations where heat detection may be considered, e.g., in the concealed space under the sink in toilet compartments or close to the trash can where the detector is expected to be in the immediate vicinity of the fire. In both the paper test and the plastic/rubber test the temperature in the concealed space under the sink was over 100 C after one minute. In very narrow spaces and in other circumstances when the detector is close to the potential fire source heat detectors will also react relatively quickly, although smoke detectors will most often still be faster. The benefits of using heat detectors in these spaces are that they are usually cheaper and more robust. They may also require less maintenance and inspections than smoke detectors that must be inspected regularly to ensure proper functioning. However, heat detectors should only be used as a complement to smoke detectors.