Discussion and Conclusion
We suggest one reason for marketing’s relative weakness in the boardroom may be the fact that market-based assets are neglected in reporting. Marketing appears relatively unimportant because the recorded assets that marketers control are modest. Furthermore, accountability for the creation and use of market-based assets is hard to achieve if these assets are rarely recorded. Fears of misleading investors may make major changes to external reports slow to arrive. Our proposed approach is valuing market-based assets in a comprehensive set of marketing accounts. Recording investments more appropriately will typically make marketing appear more profitable in the short term. One might expect marketers to welcome such a change. However, this is not a gift that all marketers will treasure. Recording market-based assets in a formal system means that marketing mistakes will be harder to hide. Recording a customer relationship asset makes the CMO accountable for the use of that asset. While this research does not address whether FASB should incorporate more valuations of market-based assets in financial accounting, we believe that change to external reporting will become more likely if companies already systematically record market-based assets in internal marketing accounts. Marketing accounts should provide a testing ground for improved valuation. Creating marketing accounts requires detailing valuation models, but there is no need to find the perfect model before implementing them. To start one needs only an off-the-shelf accounting package and the willingness to codify assumptions about how marketing works. Codifying assumptions will create a shared understanding of how marketing works and weaknesses in valuations should be reduced over time. In summary, external reporting has received considerable attention from marketing accountability advocates. We suggest another route is also worth pursuing and may be more immediately fruitful. Marketers, who are the only people with the desire and ability to improve the situation, can attempt to drive accountability by focusing on internal reporting. Marketing accounts will increase focus on marketing’s role in creating value, but in return, this will allow marketers to be held more accountable for their use and misuse of market-based assets.