4. Discussion
4.1. Molecular dynamics of LHCII in vivo and of pigment-protein complexes in vitro Cr. thylakoids are heterogeneous and contain the full photosynthetic apparatus with different protein constituents. Based on the 13C-13C NMR spectra that are dominated by LHCII we can conclude that the observed in-situ protein dynamics to large extent represent the properties of LHC proteins. Compared to the lyophilized tri-peptide model used as a control, the proteins inside thylakoids contain considerable dynamics on a microsecond to millisecond time scale, reflected by the relatively low CP/DP intensity ratios. For the LHCII aggregate sample the CP/DP ratios were even lower, implying that in the aggregates the LHCII complexes retain significant mobility that is more comparable with the dynamics of polymers or hydrogels than that of protein crystals. The INEPT spectrum of LHCII aggregates contains a small background signal typical of protein, representing a small fraction of LHCII with high mobility. This suggests that in the aggregate preparations free and aggregated LHCII co-exist in an equilibrium that is strongly shifted towards the aggregated forms. The lipid signals in the LHCII aggregate spectra are much more pronounced in CP than in INEPT, demonstrating that the contained lipids have restrained dynamics and likely are protein associated, and not free lipids from the bulk. The presence of co-purified lipids in purified LHCs is known and LHCII crystal structures of pea and spinach contain protein-associated lipids [44,45]. No significant CP signal could be detected for LHCII in detergent micelles at ambient temperatures, confirming the absence of protein aggregation. Previous data have shown that CP-based NMR spectra can be obtained of frozen protein-micelle solutions at cryogenic temperatures [42,46,47].