5. Conclusion and recommendations
Contrary to the work published by Tomc and others, this article shows a less optimistic outlook on application of thermoelectric thermal diodes in a magnetocaloric heat pump. The expected improvement in operation frequency and therefore power density is observed, but this happens in conjunction with an unwanted side effect. Heat leaking through the passive thermal diode causes a reduction in the temperature span when comparing configurations with and without the MCE enabled. In other words, a heat pump solely based on the Peltier effect shows better performance than one employing both the MCE and the Peltier effect. Next to a slightly larger temperature span, the COP differs by an order of magnitude caused by the absence of magnetic work input. The above statement is based on purely numerical work with numerous assumptions, so the first and foremost recommendation is to validate if this conclusion also holds experimentally. The numerical model itself can be improved by incorporating a thermodynamically sound implementation of the magnetocaloric effect based on the mean field theory. The power density at a realistic temperature span (e.g. a household fridge) can be determined by increasing the number of devices in series and investing more computational time. Thermal diodes of some form are essential for successful commercialization of magnetocaloric refrigeration. Based on the results of this article, Peltier thermal diodes (i.e. Micropelt MPC-D701) have lost some of their potential. Thermal switches employing geometric isolation, by for example electrowetting, might be a promising alternative (Cha [23]).